Sir Bob is not a Pleb
By The Skibbereen Eagle
Bob Geldof has described himself as a “pleb” as he defended his friend, the ex-cabinet minister Andrew Mitchell. The Irish musician submitted a written statement to the so-called “plebgate” libel trial in defence of Mr Mitchell. In it, he said of the former chief whip: “I am… a pleb and he is not.”
Mr Mitchell denies using the word and swearing at a police officer in September 2012 when he was prevented from leaving Downing Street on his bike via the main gates. The altercation led to a front-page story in the Sun and a month later to Mr Mitchell’s resignation from the government. He is suing News Group Newspapers for libel, but is himself being sued for comments he made following the incident about one of the officers on duty. PC Toby Rowland is suing Mr Mitchell for comments the MP made following their altercation and Bob Geldof has submitted his statement in defence of Andrew Mitchell.
In one of a series of written statements produced by Mr Mitchell’s legal team, Geldof described the MP as an “advocate for the less fortunate” and a “good man. I came from a poor Irish, not particularly well educated background and he does not,” he said. “I am in fact ‘a pleb’ and he is not. Never once in all our time did he patronise me, talk down to me, behave in a superior manner to me, deride, insult or dismiss me or my opinions.” Geldof said he had never heard the Conservative MP “use the ridiculous and archaic expression ‘pleb’”. 
Now this is an old plaintive “come all ye” tune about his deprived background in Dublin that Robert Zenon Geldof has played before and let me tell you it is a totally dishonest tune. Bob did have a difficult childhood due to his mother’s sudden death when he was aged 7 but he and they were no way “poor” or deprived. Bob’s saintly Dad was a hard working manufacturer’s agent who ran his own business and kept a boat at the yacht club in Dun Laoghaire, the leafy south Dublin sea side suburb where the family lived. The family home was in Crosthwaite Park, Dun Laoghaire, where today homes sell for over One Million Euros. Bob went to Blackrock College, a leading private fee paying college which counted both Eamon de Valera and Dr John McQuaid, Archbishop of Dublin, as former staff members. So Bob did not grow up in poverty and yes he left Dublin after college and worked in England (including a pea canning factory in Wisbech) and Canada but that was his choice (and entrepreneurial streak) largely due to his rebellious nature and wanderlust. His band mates in the Rats were from the same background and two of the went to the same third level institution I did and Bob had the option of going onto University but decided not to. 
Bob is not poor these days either but he as somebody who has lived and worked in the UK for 30 years is remarkably non-Domiciled in the UK for tax purposes using his Irish passport. As a non-dom he can legally avoid income and capital gains tax on international earnings, Geldof has laughed off the Sunday Times Rich List estimate of his worth (£32 million). When he has been pressed by journalist Lucy Bannerman on how much tax he has actually paid – the justification for the question being UK Foreign Aid comes from taxes – Geldof exploded. 
“I pay all my taxes,” he shouted. “My time? Is that not a tax? I employ 500 people. I have created business for the UK government. I have given my ideas. I have given half my life to this.” In a bizarre, heated exchange Geldof jabbed his finger repeatedly at Bannerman and demanded to know how many irrigation ditches she had built with her salary. The tirade ended with Geldof yelling: “How dare you lecture me about morals”, before being led away by his entourage.
Actually Bob, lots of us would like to lecture you on your tax morals if you don’t pay in full what somebody else living in the UK might owe. I stress we don’t know whether you do or not, but you had the option of saying you do and got angry instead, which makes me think you’ve got something to get angry about. 
Lucy Bannerman was absolutely right to question Bob as she did. Paying tax in the right place at the right time is a principle inextricably linked to solving the problems of poverty in Africa – and elsewhere. You can build as many ditches as you like. But candidly if you set an example by tax avoiding then you undo all your good works. It’s your choice though Bob. You’ve no need to get angry. You can just either drop the non-Dom claim or pay up instead. It’s not hard.
So next time Sir Bob plays that old untrue tune about being a mere Pleb, growing up in poverty in Dublin or paying his fair share of taxes please have to hand a large grain of salt, play the violin music louder and allow yourself to scream in The Geldof style “Bob, that’s a load of effin B##ocks!”
http://www.youtube.com/embed/TxdPpk_8CS0?feature=oembed



