The Skibbereen Eagle — Casting a Cold Eye on Life Today

November 20, 2026 · Uncategorized

A murder, a hanging – and a pardon 72 years too late?

By The Skibbereen Eagle

Harry_GleesonAlmost three quarters of a century after being sent to the gallows for a murder he had nothing to do with, Tipperary man Harry Gleeson is to become the first recipient of a posthumous pardon from the State. In 1940, Mr Gleeson walked into a Garda station in New Inn, Co Tipperary to report his discovery of a dead body. Moll McCarthy was lying in a field having suffered two shotgun blasts to the face.

In the run up to his 1941 conviction for her killing – which then carried the death penalty – the prosecution had withheld information in Mr Gleeson’s trial, encouraged witnesses to hand over falsified statements, beating one, and ignored an alibi for their suspect. Harry Gleeson, 38, was executed after a judge found him guilty of the murder of his neighbour, Mary ‘Moll’ McCarthy, known as ‘Foxy Moll’ due to her flaming red hair. A mother of seven, she was shot in the face at close range.harrydead8 HarryMollMcCarthy

In 1993 barrister and historian Marcus Bourke published Murder at Marlhill showing clearly that Harry had not killed Moll. Moll Carthy and her six children lived in a cottage adjoining land Harry managed for his marital Uncle John Caesar and she used a well on the Caesar farm to draw water. Early in life Moll had discovered that she had something men wanted, and she provided for her family through a system of barter, a thatched roof repaired by one “friend” a sack of potatoes from another. This did not go unnoticed in the prosperous Golden Vale, where land was valuable, and inheritance rights sacrosanct. Local housewives gathered outside the nearby Knockgraffon school looking at Moll’s children to see if they could see their own husbands’ likenesses on the faces of her multiplying brood. In 1926 vigilantes tried to burn Moll and her first two children out by setting her cottage on fire. As Moll’s family increased, a parish priest had to intervene to protect her, as did a local landowner’s daughter. Earlier, when a court was asked to remove the children from her care, Judge Sean Troy refused, having spoken to them and found they were being well looked after.

In 1939, Moll had her last child, a little girl called Margaret (Peggie) who only lived for six weeks. This appears to have been the trigger for the tragedy which followed. Harry found Moll’s body in a field on Caesar’s land on the morning of November 21, 1941. There are conflicting views as to who the father of that child was. Some believe it was Harry, and others point the finger at a local Garda sergeant who visited her the day before she was thought to have died. There is even doubt about when she died, and the murder charge was altered to “on or about November 20 and 21, 1941″.

harryrelatives

Justice for Harry Gleeson group discuss their campaign

Now, Harry Gleeson is to be cleared of the crime decades after it took place in a dramatic development representing the dedicated work of the Griffith College based Irish Innocence Project and the Justice for Harry Gleeson group and after a principled decision by the former Irish Minister for Justice, Alan Shatter. Part of a global organisation of the same name, the project was formed here in 2009 with the mandate of unearthing new facts in cases where there is a belief a miscarriage of justice has taken place under the remit of the Criminal Procedure Act 1993 and the posthumous pardon procedure.

“Nothing can adequately comfort those who have fought to exonerate Harry Gleeson but this posthumous pardon and the clearing of the good name of Mr Gleeson is a proud moment for everyone involved,” David Langwallner, Dean of Law at Griffith College and Project director said yesterday in the aftermath of their success.

The Department of Justice had received a submission on the case last year, claiming several threads of new evidence, much of which had been compiled by the Justice for Harry Gleeson Group which subsequently contacted the Project. It was compelling. The case review found the prosecution had successfully withheld crucial information highlighting discrepancies in their case (in particular relating to the registration of the firearm); that Gardaí encouraged witnesses to lie and beat one. Forensic evidence from a US pathologist also proved Mr Gleeson had an alibi. Her body temperature was recorded at the crime scene as 96 degrees Fahrenheit; four hours after Gleeson reported the find to police. The warmth of the victim’s body suggests she was killed that morning, however prosecution claimed that Gleeson had murdered McCarthy the previous evening.harrymountjoy_01

“This case was a tragic miscarriage of justice and the hanging of Mr Gleeson for a murder he never committed is a dark stain on the memory of the State,” said Professor Diarmuid Hegarty, president of Griffith College. “However his posthumous pardon shows that justice is not blind to injustice.” The Irish Innocence Project currently has 21 students from Griffith College, Trinity College and Dublin City University working on approximately 25 further cases under the supervision of eight lawyers working on a pro-bono basis.

harryscaffold

The “Hanging House” at Mountjoy Prison where Harry Gleeson was hanged by  British executioner Albert Pierrepoint on April 23, 1941

Gleeson, a greyhound enthusiast, was hanged at Mountjoy Prison by British executioner Albert Pierrepoint on April 23, 1941, days after Taoiseach Éamon de Valera and his cabinet rejected a mercy plea to save his life. In his final moments, Gleeson told his solicitor John Timoney and barrister Sean MacBride that he was an innocent man and hoped that whoever committed the “Murder at Marlhill” would be discovered.

The sad and tragic case of Harry Gleeson shows the casual cruelty of de Valera’s “Free” State, the moral prejudice of jurors and the rush to hang a blameless individual less than six months after a crime. In fact, one third of the hangings in independent Ireland were people involved in so called “illicit relationships.” Harry Gleeson solicitor never doubted his client’s innocence and did everything he could to defend his client. His barrister likewise fought his case tenaciously but evidence was withheld and manipulated by the State. Sean McBride was to later become Irish Minister of Foreign Affairs and is the only person to be awarded both the Nobel and the Lenin Peace prizes. Even they could not defend an innocent man from a State bent on murder. The disrespect to Harry Gleeson’s memory continues – his unmarked grave is now under a patch of tarmac in Mountjoy Prison.

Here is the Irish TV documentary on Harry Gleeson’s miscarriage of justice.

By David