Nous sommes tous Charlie Hebdo
By The Skibbereen Eagle
The 3 million copies of Charlie Hebdo printed this week sold out in 2 hours according to the French AP news bureau. That is 100 times the usual print run. A further 2 million copies are being printed thanks to the support of the left wing daily ‘Liberation’. Meanwhile, Charlie Hebdo has received over 1 million euros in donations, securing its future as a publication for the future. So the aim of silencing the journal has not only failed, but has also taken its secular, anti religious, anti fascist vulgarity to a whole new audience.
Depuis 6h30 plus aucun #CharlieHebdo chez Laurence aux Caboteurs à #Nantes. Elle n’avait que 10 exemplaires à vendre. pic.twitter.com/KPgiCpDKmc
— FranceBleuLoireOcéan (@bleuloireocean) January 14, 2015
Charlie Hebdo gained notoriety in 2006 for its portrayal of a sobbing Muhammad, under the headline “Mahomet débordé par les intégristes” (“Muhammad overwhelmed by fundamentalists”). Within its pages, the magazine published 12 cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad, bringing unprecedented condemnation from the Muslim world. The French Council for the Muslim Faith eventually sued the weekly for the cartoon. The issue has since been considered the one which positioned Charlie Hebdo as a target for terrorist attacks.
— Christianne avec 2 N (@ChrisDeGrasse) January 7, 2015
France is a secular Republic founded on the principles of Liberté, Égalité et Fraternité. The Revolution left a deep anti-clericalism as the Church was very much part of the control mechanism of the Ancien Régime swept aside by the cauldron of the Revolution and separated from the Civil State by Napoleon’s reforms. In France, you are not supposed to show any sign of your religion and by law you can’t wear a cross at work, or a veil. It is in fact illegal in a census or any form to ask a person what is their religion so the French State does not actually know what religion its citizens are and traditionally has cared even less. It is all about creating a common ground, whatever your background might be. 

Strange then to see the tokenism of world leaders “marching” in a cordoned off side street such as Benjamin Netanyahu whose forces recently killed 17 Journalists and 500 children in Gaza, King Abdullah II of Jordan who recently jailed a journalist for 15 years and where you can be jailed for “disturbing relations with a foreign state” among many other nebulous offences and Irish Prime Minister Enda Kenny whose Government in this the 21st Century has introduced a Blasphemy Law! Now that is an interesting concept which essentially says all these religions should be immune from criticism even though their central USP, that you will live after you die, does not have one iota of evidence to support it. While we are at it the evidence on the “God Question” is somewhat the same as the evidence on the “Werewolf Question.” If you cannot satirise human delusion and vanity what hope is there of us moving on from the primitive mind set of Bronze Age Man?

Charlie Hebdo and its biting satire was not to everybody’s taste. It seemed to take pride in being offensive and was in the revolutionary tradition of strident anti-clericalism with a tone which seemed to regard all religions as a pox upon humanity, a somewhat widespread view among those of us who believe Man created God. It was a minority, perpetually in crisis and normally selling just 60,000 copies. This week after the attack it has raised a million euros from backers and is printing 5 million copies with a cartoon of a weeping Prophet Mohamed on the cover – in Islamic tradition the Prophet of Islam like God is never depicted, both from the Biblical prohibition on “graven images” and the prohibition on Idolatry . Charlie Hebdo was anti-religious having had no less than 14 cases taken against it by the Catholic Church.
To many it appeared to be the perpetual Student Rag Mag being produced by people too old to be students. It was in the French Revolutionary and Humanist tradition. In the tradition of the Age of Enlightenment and in the City of Light it stayed true to the precept of Voltaire “I do not agree with what you say but I will defend to the death your right to say it.”
It would be a fitting tribute to the Charlie Hebdo journalists if we could rekindle that spirit. Nous sommes Voltaire – now more than ever, we should all be with Voltaire.


