Moorgate Tube Train Disaster
By The Skibbereen Eagle
Forty years ago today London Underground suffered its worst fatal incident with the Moorgate Tube Train disaster. The Moorgate tube crash occurred on Friday 28 February 1975 at 08:46 on the Northern City Line, then operated by London Underground as the Northern line (Highbury Branch). A southbound train failed to stop at the Moorgate terminus and crashed into the wall at the end of the tunnel. Forty-three people died as a result of the crash, the greatest loss of life during peacetime on the London Underground, and a further seventy-four were injured. With no fault being found with the train equipment, the Department of the Environment report found that the driver had failed to slow the train and stop at the station and there was insufficient evidence to determine the cause.
This is a station where all the platforms are nominally underground, on three levels. The top level, which is really a cut and partial cover, has the Circle, Metropolitan and City lines passing through and serves as a terminus for a branch line of the Thameslink service to Bedford. The intermediate level is the terminus for a branch of the WAGN service out to Cambridge and the Anglia Region. The bottom Level is where the Northern line passes through. All in all, this is a large, busy station with only the entrances showing above ground. On 28 February 1975 a London Underground train crashed at Moorgate station, killing 43 (including the Driver) and injuring many more. The train, arriving from Drayton Park, was packed with commuters when it overshot the platform and ploughed into a dead-end tunnel. 

A train travelling downhill into Moorgate (the last station on this short line) sped through the station and crashed into the wall at the end. As rescue workers prepared a long fight to bring all the injured out of the mangle of compressed carriages, a full-scale investigation was set up into the Moorgate tube disaster.
There was a lot of speculation on what caused the crash. The key question is why the driver, Leslie Newson, aged 56, accelerated into the blind tunnel when his 8.37am commuter train from Drayton Park should have been braking. It sped past platform nine at twice the usual speed of 15mph and then ran out of track.

The first three of the six coaches telescoped at the end of the 80-yard tunnel after crashing through sand piles and over the buffers. Many of the dead had been found beneath the first carriage; the first fifteen feet had been compacted down to two feet and is embedded in the end wall. All that day teams of doctors, fireman and nurses wrestled with the wreckage, in dust and withering heat, attempting to reach those still alive. A teenage policewoman was carried out after twelve hours. One of her feet had been pinned down by the tangle of metal and had to be amputated at the scene.![Moorgate Tube Train Disaster moorgate_disaster[1]](https://web.archive.org/web/20150303054128im_/http://www.skibbereeneagle.ie/web/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/moorgate_disaster1-300x228.jpg)
The driver was elderly, so heart attack or something similar was assumed. The trains are fitted with a “dead-man’s hand”, which has to be held in position manually all the time, so that if a driver has a heart attack, for example, and released this, the train would brake automatically. The British tabloids made several outrageous claims, including that the dead-man’s hand was held in place with some object, that traces of whiskey were found in the driver’s flask, that the guard was negligent, and so on.
A memorial plaque is affixed to the side of the station building, in Moor Place. In July 2013 a memorial was unveiled, listing those who died, in the south-west corner of Finsbury Square, 450 yards north of Moorgate station
In fact no satisfactory explanation has ever been given for the cause of the Moorgate disaster. The driver of the death train had been in perfect health, was found not to be suffering from alcohol or drugs, and was very unlikely to have committed suicide – he had cash on him to buy his daughter a car that afternoon. He was also known as steady and reliable – not the suicidal type. He had also been with the Underground since 1969 and was known to be a careful, conscientious driver, the only thing sullying his record was a single instance of slightly overrunning a platform. The guard admitted that he had not noticed the train getting faster, as he had been sat down, reading a newspaper. People on the platform when the train arrived all said they could see the driver sitting in his cab, looking straight ahead, and apparently holding his controls, including the “deadman’s handle”, in the normal position. Investigations carried out after the crash confirmed this, and the unfortunate driver had not even raised his hands to protect his face at the moment of impact. 
Nothing was wrong with the train, or the signalling equipment and track. So what did happen? Possibly he “ran out of railway”. In those days you had to work as a Guard before you could apply for a Train Driver’s job and Leslie Newson had been a driver for only 3 months. From Drayton Park to Moorgate took only 10 minutes and the driver had made that journey 4 times already that day. Sometimes a driver goes into a state of mind where he is detached from the railway and becomes myopic. If this happens at a station you can sometimes overrun or miss it altogether, and continue on to the next station. The reason for the overshoot was never satisfactorily determined by the subsequent inquiry. London Undergrounds’ signaling systems today are designed to stop a similar incident.
There has been no real closure for the families of the victims of this disaster. You have to respect the verdict of “no known cause.” The inquiry reports details of medical causes that may have caused the driver to become incapacitated yet sadly could not be proven , and also how suicide was also unlikely. We can only give our sympathy for all involved in this dreadful accident including the driver and his own family who must have also suffered.
http://www.youtube.com/embed/IzNuOAW2lVc?feature=oembed



