Eileen Clark, the woman who fled ‘abusive’ husband in US is extradited on parental kidnap charges
By The Skibbereen Eagle
A case today has once again thrown into sharp relief the great unfairness of the UK–US extradition treaty of 2003 with the extradition of mother of three Eileen Clark to the United States over a family law dispute going back 20 years. The US very rarely extradites its own citizens to other jurisdictions but has taken onto itself in this act the power to extradite UK citizens even when no wrongdoing is alleged in the United States. People extradited to the US are always treated as absconders from justice, routinely denied bail and sent to high security jails where they are often kept in solitary confinement . They are not afforded legal aid and accordingly often have no effective way of defending themselves in a foreign jurisdiction and are forced to accept plea bargains. Also because the US does not have to present a prima facie case in a UK Court people can be extradited for offences which are not illegal in the UK, such as trading with Cuba which is subject to an economic blockade by the United States which is itself illegal under International Law.
Today an American mother-of-three who fled her allegedly abusive husband more than a decade ago has been extradited from the UK on charges of “international parental kidnapping”. Eileen Clark, 54, who had been living in West Way, Oxford, was put on a plane at London’s Heathrow Airport by police officers. Lawyers for Clark said she had been “openly” living in Britain since December 1998 and had laid down “deep roots”. In April 2012, they argued that it would be unlawful and “oppressive” to extradite her because of her psychiatric problems. Mercifully, US air marshals have said they won’t restrain her throughout today’s flight providing she “conducts herself appropriately”. However she is extremely agitated and distraught – behaviour which we fear may yet be interpreted as “inappropriate”.
The Home Secretary maintained the original extradition order last August, but the case returned to court following human rights submissions and a new diagnosis that Clark was suffering from post traumatic stress disorder related to a history of domestic violence in the 1990s. Last month, Lord Justice Treacy and Mr Justice Nicol at the High Court in London rejected her latest appeal. The judge said the removal of children without parental consent was a “serious matter” which was recognised as such by both domestic and foreign courts. Lord Justice Treacy added that the court was “dubious” about the PTSD claim, stating a “cogent case” had not been established. 
Sandra Horley, chief executive of domestic violence charity Refuge, told BBC News that today was a “bleak day. It is highly disturbing that her claims have not been properly examined in a court of law in this country,” she said. “Instead, this terrified woman is being handed back to the States to face criminal charges.” Clark was arrested at her Oxfordshire home in July 2010, after the American government requested her return. Her first husband, John Clark, began legal proceedings against her when she left their home in New Mexico with their children and moved to a friend’s home in California. She was charged with “custodial interference” after leaving her husband in 1995, but instructed a US lawyer and believed the charge had been dismissed. However 15 years on, in 2010, she was informed out of the blue that she was to be extradited for international parental kidnapping. 
In June 1995, state prosecutors charged her with “custodial interference”. Two years later, the marriage was dissolved with both parents retaining legal custody. Although her former husband never saw the children while they were growing up, he continued to pursue his case against her through the US courts. Mrs Clark was eventually indicted by a grand jury with charges of “international parental kidnapping” after she fled to the UK. Human rights charity Liberty, which took on her case when she exhausted her appeal rights, said: “The very strong and compelling evidence that Eileen was a victim of serious domestic violence and abuse was not properly considered by the courts in this country.”
There has been a great deal of guff in the media about British loss of Sovereignty, normally and allegedly in relation to the EU, where the UK has a vote and representation. Compare that to the situation where the US has effectively hijacked the British legal system, intercepts our data and ceded vast areas of commerce to US companies such as Google, Amazon & Starbucks who trade in the UK but do not pay taxes in the country where they make their profits.
Is it not time to reclaim our Sovereignty from the country which does not respect it? Ms Clark said she sees the extradition as just another part of her ex-husband’s abuse. “He is trying to destroy me,” she has said. It is hard to see how this vindictive and shabby extradition serves the interests of justice or of Eileen Clark’s children?
Eileen Clark fled the US in 1998 with her three children, including son Chandler and daughter Rebekah


