The Skibbereen Eagle — Casting a Cold Eye on Life Today

November 20, 2026 · Music

Band Aid 30: Don’t they know it’s smugness

By The Skibbereen Eagle

bandaid30confLily Allen has become the latest artist to criticise the Band Aid single in aid of the Ebola crisis, revealing that she refused to appear on it because she considered it smug and preferred to donate “actual money”. The charity single is poised to top the British charts on Sunday, having become the fastest selling single of the year, but that has not stopped a backlash from people who have accused it of being patronising and perpetuating misconceptions about Africa.

band_aid

Do they know it’s Christmas time at all? Photo: YouTube screengrab

'The Jonathan Ross Show' TV Programme, London, Britain. - 08 Nov 2014

Lily Allen has weighed into the Band Aid debate, saying she thought the song was smug

“I prefer to do my charitable bit by donating actual money and not being lumped in with a bunch of people like that. It’s like the ‘success club’ and I’m not really in that club. I don’t think I’m above it all – I’m way below it. But there’s something a bit smug about it.” Well Lily here is some evidence to support the way you feel.

The Band Aid participants have done a behind-the-scenes video, in which they get helicoptered to lunch at PR guru Matthew Freud’s enormous zoellamansion, which has “strawberries – everything”. The Band Aid supergroup show us their bizarre behind-the-scenes helicopter trip to the head of Freud Communications, Matthew Freud’s, enormous house. It has Vespas, pigs and strawberries. And who are these Titans of the music industry lending their gravitas to this serious attempt to highlight the Ebola Crisis? Why none other than “Star” You Tube vloggers Zoe Suggs (aka Zoella) and her boyfriend Alfie Deyes. Zoellas inane chatter reinforces the age-old premise that women must be beautiful if they are to lead happy lives, and that what they care about, above all else, is how to do a flawless festival-ready top knot. That Dear Reader is why she is “bigger” than Beyonce on You Tube, has a Penguin book deal, a bespoke beauty range, and two Teen Choice awards to her name and her and her equally vacuous boyfriend were in the chorus line for Band Aid 30 and helicoptering to PR Man’s mansion afterwards. Get the connection to Music / Africa? Me neither.

http://www.youtube.com/embed/oLIpH15OxCQ?feature=oembed&start=57

Geldof has rejected criticism of Band Aid and its participants out of hand, telling Sky News the dissenting voices were “talking bollocks”. Here is Sir Bob-a-Job’s idea of respectful and meaningful debate on the issues facing Africa. Sky News presenter Jayne Secker asked Geldof to respond to critical reactions to the re-recording of the Do They Know It’s Christmas? single for victims of Ebola: “A lot of people are saying, ‘look at all the people in that room, a lot of wealthy people, if they all paid their taxes in the right way, we wouldn’t need these kind of fund-raising singles.’ What would you say to that?”

http://www.youtube.com/embed/TxdPpk_8CS0?feature=oembed

By David